Market Pulse:
KSE-100:89,240.50+1.62%
USD/PKR:277.85-0.15%
EUR/PKR:302.40+0.08%
GBP/PKR:361.20-0.22%
GOLD:274,500+0.45%
BRENT:76.40-0.85%
IT-EXP:$310M+24.8%
Market Pulse:
KSE-100:89,240.50+1.62%
internationalDateline: Karachi, Pakistan

Tim Hortons App Sends Customer Data to Israeli Intelligence

Tim Hortons App faces privacy concerns over customer device data shared with Israeli founded cybersecurity firm Forter.
Tim Hortons App faces privacy concerns over customer device data shared with Israeli founded cybersecurity firm Forter.
Focus Pakistan Verification Notice: This article was fact-checked by our editorial board against primary regulatory filings and direct on-the-ground bureau reporting in Karachi.
Coffee chain faces fresh privacy questions as researchers uncover extensive device tracking and links to Israel's Unit 8200.*

TORONTO, Nov. 18 (Focus Pakistan) – The Tim Hortons App faces fresh privacy scrutiny after researchers uncovered extensive customer device data collection involving an Israeli-founded cybersecurity company whose founders previously served in Israel's military intelligence unit. The findings raise serious questions about how much personal information customers surrender simply by ordering coffee.

The controversy deepened after Canadian advocacy group Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CJPME) identified the data recipient as Forter, an Israeli-founded cybersecurity company whose founders previously served in Israel's military intelligence unit.

The revelations raise an uncomfortable question: Why does a coffee chain need detailed information about customers' phones, nearby Wi-Fi networks and personal device settings?

What Your Coffee App Knows About You

CBC Marketplace examined popular mobile applications with University of Calgary cybersecurity researcher Joel Reardon. Researchers found that the Tim Hortons app began transmitting information to third-party services immediately after launch, before customers even placed an order.

The information included unique device identifiers, camera specifications, hardware sensors, ringtone names, alarm sounds and nearby Wi-Fi networks. Those details may appear harmless individually. Together, however, they can create a distinctive digital fingerprint that allows companies to recognize devices across different sessions.
Also Read: Spy Scandal Fells Huang; Trump Pushes Tim Cook for Nvidia
Nearby Wi-Fi network names also provide location clues, potentially revealing where someone lives, works or regularly travels without requiring GPS coordinates. For customers expecting a simple coffee-ordering service, the scale of collection raises questions about privacy and consent.

Israeli Military Intelligence Connection Sparks Alarm

On November 17, CJPME publicly identified Forter as the overseas company receiving information from the Tim Hortons app. Forter's founders, Michael Reitblat, Liron Damri and Alon Shemesh, previously served in Unit 8200, Israel's military signals intelligence organization.

The unit's surveillance activities have attracted international scrutiny, particularly over intelligence operations involving Palestinians.

CJPME urged Tim Hortons to terminate its relationship with Forter and questioned whether customers understood the company's intelligence-related background. However, the founders' military histories do not establish that Forter shares customer information with Israel's armed forces.

The investigation provides no evidence that Tim Hortons transfers customer data directly to the Israeli military.

Tim Hortons Defends Its Data Collection

Tim Hortons rejected suggestions that the information serves advertising or marketing purposes. The company said its security partners collect device information to prevent fraud, protect accounts and identify suspicious payment activity.

Such systems can detect unfamiliar devices, account impersonation attempts and potentially fraudulent transactions. Tim Hortons also maintained that its partners cannot sell the information and that the company does not sell customers' personal data to outside brokers.

The dispute therefore centres on whether fraud prevention justifies collecting such extensive device information. This controversy follows an earlier investigation that exposed serious privacy failures involving the same coffee chain.

In 2022, Canadian privacy regulators concluded that Tim Hortons violated privacy laws by collecting excessive location information without meaningful consent. Investigators discovered that the app monitored customers' movements even when they were not using it.

One customer's phone recorded more than 2,700 location observations in fewer than five months. The information allowed the company to identify homes, workplaces, travel patterns and visits to competing businesses.Tim Hortons stopped the disputed location-tracking practice in 2020 following regulatory scrutiny.

The Bigger Question for Customers
The latest findings highlight a growing concern about everyday mobile applications: customers may surrender far more personal information than the service actually requires.

Fraud prevention remains a legitimate business need. But companies must explain what information they collect, who receives it and why less intrusive alternatives cannot achieve the same result.For Tim Hortons customers, the controversy extends beyond coffee.

The real question is whether ordering a drink should also mean handing over a detailed fingerprint of your digital life.
Filed Under:#Tim Hortons#Tim Hortons Data Privacy#Tim Hortons Israel Connection#Forter Israeli Intelligence#Tim Hortons Customer Data

Reader Discussion (…)

Moderated per Focus Pakistan Community Code

Join the Editorial Conversation

Loading comments…

More Coverage In international

View Entire Desk →